Resources · Free Tool
5.0 · Built from 250+ merchant switches in Tampa Bay
Know what to look for
before signing with a
payment processor
The right merchant account should make your business easier to run, not harder. Use this checklist to compare processors, spot red flags, and ask the right questions before you sign anything.
Free educational resource · No commitment · Save it, share it, use it
10 critical points
8 red flags to watch
5 pricing models explained
$500 rate match guarantee
10
Critical Checklist Items
8
Red Flags Covered
$0
Cost to Compare
5.0★
Google Rating
Scroll
The Checklist
10 things to compare before signing with a processor
Not all merchant accounts are created equal. Some processors hide bad terms behind low teaser rates, long contracts, or vague promises. These are the categories worth reviewing carefully before you commit.
Flexible Payment Options for Terminals
Are you locked into long-term rental contracts, or does the processor give you flexible options to buy or lease-to-own terminals without getting trapped in an overpriced agreement?
Future-Proof Terminals
Are the terminals designed to accept chip technology and modern payment methods, or will you be forced to upgrade later at a painful cost?
Meet or Beat Pricing
Is the processor flexible enough to offer your business a competitive rate without making you jump through hoops, meet strange conditions, or negotiate like you're buying a used car?
Quick Access to Cash
Does the processor offer quick funding and flexible financing options to support business growth, or are there restrictions, fixed payments, and interest-heavy terms attached?
Ease of Integration
Will the processor work with your current setup, software, or custom workflow? Can you import or export customer data easily without starting from scratch?
Security and PCI Compliance
Does the processor use serious fraud and security tools to protect your business and your customers, and do they meet PCI standards so your business stays compliant?
Real-Time Reporting
Can you monitor performance anytime from anywhere, and can you export reports in the formats you actually need, like Excel, PDF, or other standard file types?
Gateway Features and User Access
Can you manage recurring payments, re-billing, and repeat transactions without re-entering customer information every time? Can you also control staff permissions with customizable user access levels?
Dedicated Merchant Support
Can the processor help with chargebacks, risk monitoring, technical issues, and day-to-day support? Are they actually available when you need them, including weekends and emergencies?
Guaranteed Rates
Does the processor guarantee no rate increases in your processing fees, or are you just waiting for the quiet markup creep that shows up later on your statement?
Pricing Models Decoded
Five ways processors price merchant accounts.
Most business owners don't realize how many different ways a processor can structure your fees — or that the structure matters more than the headline rate. Each model has tradeoffs, and most processors deliberately make their structure hard to compare.
Here's the quick-reference on what each model is, who it benefits, and which one we use by default.
Tiered Pricing (Qual / Mid-Qual / Non-Qual)
Processor groups your cards into buckets · Almost always hides markup
Blended Flat-Rate (Square, Stripe)
2.6-2.9% on everything · Simple but expensive over ~$15K/mo volume
Subscription / Membership Pricing
Fixed monthly fee + interchange pass-through · Works for high-volume only
Dual Pricing / Cash Discount
Card customers pay the processing · Merchant pays $0 in card fees
Interchange Plus (Tampa Bay Pay default)
Wholesale interchange cost + small fixed markup · Fully transparent
Red Flags
Eight tricks the industry uses
to overcharge you
to overcharge you
If you see any of these in a sales pitch, statement, or contract — slow down.
1 / 8
Seen any of these on your statement? Send it to us. We'll translate it, identify the markups, and show you exactly what's costing you what.
Free Statement Translation →
How to Use This Checklist
Bring this checklist to your next processor conversation
You don't need to be an industry expert to protect your business. You just need the right questions. Use this checklist when reviewing your current provider or comparing a new one.
A simple way to compare processors:
1Ask each provider these exact questions and see how clear or evasive they get.
2Request answers in writing whenever possible, especially around pricing, contracts, and equipment terms.
3Compare total value, not just the teaser rate. Bad support and bad hardware can cost more than a fraction of a point ever saves.
4If something sounds vague, complicated, or weirdly hard to explain — that's usually the point.
Frequently Asked Questions
Merchant account questions — answered
What's the difference between interchange plus and tiered pricing?
Interchange plus shows you the actual wholesale cost (interchange + assessments paid to Visa/Mastercard) plus a small, fixed markup your processor adds. Tiered pricing groups all transactions into "qualified," "mid-qualified," and "non-qualified" buckets at progressively higher rates — and the processor decides which bucket your transactions fall into. Tiered pricing almost always costs more because cards that should be priced lower get bumped into higher tiers. Interchange plus is the transparent industry standard.
How can I read my current processing statement?
Look for: effective rate (total fees ÷ total volume × 100), interchange charges (should be itemized), assessment fees (Visa/MC pass-through), processor markup, monthly fees (PCI, statement, gateway, batch). A clear statement shows all of these separately. A confusing statement bundles them into "discount rate" or vague line items. If you can't quickly calculate your effective rate, that's by design — and worth sending to us for a free review.
What's a reasonable PCI compliance fee?
The actual industry-passed PCI program cost is typically $5-$10 per month, and many processors include the SAQ (Self-Assessment Questionnaire) at no additional fee. If you're paying $15-$40+ monthly for "PCI compliance," you're being marked up — that's profit, not cost. Some processors also charge "non-compliance" fees of $30-$50 when you haven't completed paperwork, even if you're actually compliant. Both are red flags.
Should I ever sign a multi-year processor contract?
Rarely. Multi-year contracts with early termination fees ($295-$795+ is common) exist because the processor knows their pricing or service won't hold up. Month-to-month service is the industry trend, and it's what we offer. If a processor pushes a 2-3 year contract, ask what specifically they're worried about that they need to lock you in to protect.
Are flat-rate processors like Square ever a good choice?
For very small businesses doing under ~$5,000/month in card volume, flat-rate processors like Square can be cost-effective because the markup matters less and the setup is dead-simple. Above that volume, the math turns. At $15,000+/month in card volume, an interchange-plus account typically saves you several hundred dollars monthly. Above $50,000/month, the savings get serious. The exception: businesses that explicitly value Square's free POS app and accept higher processing as the cost.
What's a "qualified" vs "non-qualified" transaction?
Under tiered pricing, processors classify your transactions into buckets — "qualified" (lowest rate), "mid-qualified" (medium), "non-qualified" (highest). The catch: rewards cards, corporate cards, manually-keyed transactions, and certain online transactions almost always get pushed into mid-qual or non-qual, regardless of what the processor implied in their pitch. You see a low "qualified" rate in the sales pitch and end up paying the mid-qual or non-qual rate in practice. Interchange plus eliminates this game entirely.
How do I know if I'm being overcharged?
The simplest test: divide your total processing fees from last month by your total card volume, then multiply by 100. That's your effective rate. Industries typical: 2.4-2.9% on retail, 2.8-3.4% on restaurants, 3.2-3.8% on phone/online B2B. If your effective rate is significantly above your industry norm, you're overpaying — by a lot in some cases. Send us your statement for a side-by-side comparison and we'll show you exactly where the money's going.
Can I switch processors mid-contract?
Yes, but it depends on the early termination fee (ETF) and your remaining contract length. We've helped merchants do the math both ways — sometimes the monthly savings recover the ETF in 2-3 months; sometimes it makes sense to wait out the contract. Either way, we'll show you the actual numbers so you can decide. Many processors also have ETF buyout programs we can navigate.
Related Resources
More tools and reading
Want a Second Opinion?
Let Tampa Bay Pay review your current setup before you switch
We can review your existing pricing, equipment, and contract terms, then show you where the red flags are and what better options may look like for your business.
Call or Text: (727) 732-3292 · [email protected] · By Appointment Only
Real Merchants · Real Results
What Our Clients Are Saying
Tampa Bay businesses share their experience working with Tampa Bay Pay — from setup through ongoing support.
Joto's Pizza
Jodi Whitcomb, Owner · jotospizza.com
Family-owned for 52 years. Upgraded to FigurePOS — caller ID integration, customizable menus, and a system staff learn fast without extensive training.
Florida Orange Groves Winery
Lance Shooks, Owner · floridawine.com
When QuickBooks stopped processing credit cards, Tampa Bay Pay provided a seamless integration — keeping their existing QuickBooks setup without an expensive POS replacement.
Plumbing by Paul
Paul & Alycia Alves, Owners · plumbingbypaulllc.com
Tampa Bay Pay goes beyond payment processing — always reachable by phone, text, or email, and a valuable partner for Google SEO, social media, and web support.
Plumbing by Paul
Paul Alves · plumbingbypaulllc.com
Previous provider had frequent errors and slow funding. New setup processes payments reliably in the field and at the office — with next-day funding that's critical for a small business.
Wrenchmasters
Kenny Gehringer, Owner · wrenchmastersauto.com
Previous processor only offered a 1-800 number. Switched for local support and streamlined technology — now sends invoices and processes tap-to-pay even when internet is spotty.
Google Reviews · Tampa Bay Pay
The Highest Rated Payment Team in Tampa Bay
Don't take our word for it — here's what local business owners say after switching to Tampa Bay Pay.
5.0
Google Rating
Verified Reviews
Verified Reviews