Free checklist

Know what to look for before you sign.

The right merchant account should make your business easier to run, not harder. Use this checklist to compare processors, spot red flags and ask the right questions before you sign anything.

10
Things to compare
8
Red flags
5
Pricing models explained
$0
Cost to compare
The checklist

10 things to compare before signing with a processor

Some processors hide bad terms behind low teaser rates, long contracts or vague promises. Ask every provider about each of these, and get the answers in writing.

  1. Equipment terms

    Can you buy equipment outright, or are you pushed into a rental or lease? Ask whether any lease can be cancelled and what happens to it if you leave.

  2. Modern, future-proof equipment

    Does the equipment accept chip, tap and digital wallets, or will you be forced into an expensive upgrade soon?

  3. Competitive pricing without games

    Will they quote you a clear, competitive rate up front, without strange conditions or volume promises you have to hit?

  4. Fast access to your money

    How quickly do deposits land? Ask about funding times, cutoff times and any holds or reserves.

  5. Works with what you use

    Will it connect to your POS, website, accounting or invoicing software, and can you move your customer data if you leave?

  6. Security and PCI compliance

    What fraud tools come with the account, who helps you stay PCI compliant, and what does any PCI fee actually cover?

  7. Reporting you can use

    Can you see sales and deposits anytime, and export reports in formats like Excel or PDF?

  8. Online and recurring features

    Can you store cards securely, run recurring billing and set user permissions for your staff?

  9. Real support

    Who helps with chargebacks, technical problems and day-to-day questions? Ask how to reach them, and what's available after hours.

  10. Pricing that stays put

    Is their markup locked in, or can they raise it whenever they want? Card network fees can change, but the processor's own markup shouldn't creep up.

Pricing models decoded

Five ways processors price your account

The pricing structure often matters more than the headline rate, and some structures are deliberately hard to compare. Here's what each one means.

  • Tiered (qualified / mid / non-qualified)Your cards are sorted into buckets the processor controls
    Avoid
  • Flat rate (Square, Stripe)One simple rate on everything, often costly as you grow
    Simple, pricey
  • Subscription / membershipMonthly fee plus wholesale cost, best at higher volume
    Depends
  • Dual pricing / cash discountCard payers cover the cost, so yours can drop close to $0
    Close to $0
  • Interchange-plus (our standard)Wholesale card cost plus a fixed, visible markup
    Transparent
Red flags

Eight things that should make you slow down

  • Red flag 01

    The teaser rate

    A very low "qualified" rate in the pitch that only applies to a small share of your cards. Rewards, business, keyed and online cards cost much more.

    How to spot itAsk: "What will I actually pay on a rewards card swiped at my counter?" A vague answer is your answer.
  • Red flag 02

    Tiered pricing buckets

    The processor decides which tier each sale lands in, and the costly cards tend to land in the expensive tiers.

    How to spot itLook for "qualified," "mid-qualified" and "non-qualified" lines on your statement. Ask for interchange-plus instead.
  • Red flag 03

    Padded PCI fees

    Monthly PCI fees that seem high for what they cover, plus "non-compliance" fees if paperwork isn't done.

    How to spot itFind every PCI line on your statement and ask exactly what it pays for and how to avoid non-compliance fees.
  • Red flag 04

    Equipment lease traps

    A non-cancellable lease can cost far more than the equipment. For example, $79 a month for 48 months is $3,792, and leases often continue even after you switch processors.

    How to spot itLook for "non-cancellable," the lease length and buyout terms before you sign anything.
  • Red flag 05

    Contracts that auto-renew

    Multi-year terms that renew automatically unless you cancel in a narrow window, with early termination fees if you leave.

    How to spot itLook for "initial term," "renewal term" and "early termination fee." Month-to-month is the standard to ask for.
  • Red flag 06

    Confusing statements

    Cryptic line items, no clear effective rate and fees scattered across pages make comparing hard.

    How to spot itDivide total fees by total card sales to get your effective rate. If you can't find the numbers, send us the statement.
  • Red flag 07

    "Free" equipment with strings

    Free hardware that's only free with a long contract, higher rates or a return requirement.

    How to spot itAsk whether free equipment requires a contract and what happens if you leave. Ours comes with month-to-month processing.
  • Red flag 08

    Quiet markup increases

    Contracts that let the processor raise its markup at any time, often in small, vaguely explained increments.

    How to spot itCheck your effective rate every few months. If it climbs without a reason you agreed to, ask why.
How to use this checklist

Bring it to your next processor conversation

You don't need to be an industry expert to protect your business. You just need the right questions.

  1. Ask each provider these questions and notice how clear or evasive the answers are.
  2. Get answers in writing, especially on pricing, contracts and equipment.
  3. Compare total cost and value, not just the headline rate. Poor support and bad equipment can cost more than a fraction of a percent saves.
  4. If something sounds vague or oddly hard to explain, treat that as a warning sign.
Questions

Merchant account FAQ

What's the difference between interchange-plus and tiered pricing?

Interchange-plus shows the wholesale cost set by the card networks plus a fixed markup from your processor. Tiered pricing sorts your sales into buckets at different rates, and the processor decides which bucket each sale lands in. Interchange-plus is usually easier to understand and compare.

How do I read my processing statement?

Start by finding your total card sales and total fees. Divide fees by sales and multiply by 100 to get your effective rate. Then look for interchange (the card network cost), your processor's markup and monthly fees like PCI, statement or gateway fees. If the statement makes this hard, send it to us for a free review.

What should I know about PCI fees?

PCI compliance is required, and many processors charge a monthly fee for their PCI program. Ask what the fee covers, whether help with your questionnaire is included and how to avoid non-compliance fees. Compare it across providers, since it varies widely.

Should I sign a multi-year processing contract?

Be careful. Long contracts often come with auto-renewal and early termination fees. Month-to-month service lets you leave if the service or pricing stops working for you, and it's what we offer.

Are flat-rate processors like Square ever a good choice?

They can be for very small or brand-new businesses that value simplicity. As your card sales grow, a flat rate often costs more than interchange-plus or dual pricing. A free rate review will show you where your break-even point is.

How do I know if I'm being overcharged?

Calculate your effective rate and compare it month to month and against quotes from other providers. Watch for tiered pricing, padded monthly fees and markup increases. We'll show you a side-by-side comparison for free.

Can I switch processors in the middle of a contract?

Usually yes, but there may be an early termination fee. Sometimes the savings cover it quickly, and sometimes it makes sense to wait for your renewal window. We'll help you run the numbers.

5.0 from 176 Google reviews
Get a Free Rate Review

Want a second opinion on your current setup?

Send us your statement and contract terms. We'll point out any red flags and show you what better looks like, with no pressure to switch.

Call or text (727) 732-3292 · [email protected]

Real Merchants · Real Results

What Our Clients Are Saying

Tampa Bay businesses share their experience working with Tampa Bay Pay — from setup through ongoing support.

Joto's Pizza

Jodi Whitcomb, Owner  ·  jotospizza.com
Family-owned for 52 years. Upgraded to FigurePOS — caller ID integration, customizable menus, and a system staff learn fast without extensive training.
Restaurant FigurePOS Seminole, FL

Florida Orange Groves Winery

Lance Shooks, Owner  ·  floridawine.com
When their QuickBooks card processing stopped working for them, Tampa Bay Pay set up a seamless integration — keeping their existing QuickBooks setup without an expensive POS replacement.
Winery & Retail QuickBooks Integration St. Pete Beach, FL

Plumbing by Paul

Paul & Alycia Alves, Owners  ·  plumbingbypaulllc.com
Tampa Bay Pay goes beyond payment processing — always reachable by phone, text, or email, and a valuable partner for Google SEO, social media, and web support.
Plumbing & Trade Dual Pricing Tampa Bay, FL

Plumbing by Paul

Paul Alves  ·  plumbingbypaulllc.com
Previous provider had frequent errors and slow funding. New setup processes payments reliably in the field and at the office — with next-day funding that's critical for a small business.
Plumbing & Trade Next-Day Funding Mobile Payments

Wrenchmasters

Kenny Gehringer, Owner  ·  wrenchmastersauto.com
Previous processor only offered a 1-800 number. Switched for local support and streamlined technology — now sends invoices and processes tap-to-pay even when internet is spotty.
Auto Service Tampa Bay, FL
Featured On · The Paycast Network

Zac on The Paycast Network

Founder Zac Gottlieb joined The Paycast Network to talk transparency, interchange, and what it really takes to build a payments brand local businesses trust.

Why Most Processors Hide Their Real Fees

Zac Gottlieb with host Chase  ·  The Paycast Network
Breaking down interchange rates, the hidden costs of flat-rate pricing, and why merchant processors should be held to the same professional standards as CPAs, lawyers, and bankers.
Transparency Interchange Jun 2026

Handshakes, High Standards & Einstein's Hair

Zac Gottlieb, with Andrew Gill & Clay Shivers  ·  The Paycast Network
A roundtable on building a standout payments brand in 2026 — why branding is a stamina game, and why in an automated world the person behind the terminal is still your most valuable asset.
Branding Roundtable May 2026
Google Reviews · Tampa Bay Pay

5.0 Stars from 176 Google Reviews

Don't take our word for it — here's what local business owners say after switching to Tampa Bay Pay.

5.0
Google Rating
176 Reviews